Volkswagen Group: Transition Tested by Margin Erosion and the Asian Challenge

Volkswagen Group, Europe's leading car manufacturer, is facing a pivotal moment in its history. While consolidated revenue demonstrates remarkable resilience, reaching nearly €325 billion in 2024 (a 5% CAGR since 2019), the composition of this growth reveals worrying disparities. The company, spanning mass-market brands (VW, Skoda, SEAT) to luxury (Porsche, Audi, Bentley) and heavy trucks (TRATON), is executing a "value over volume" strategic pivot that is struggling to stabilize operational profitability amidst fierce competition, particularly in China.

Segment Performance Analysis: Profitability Under Pressure

The analysis of 2024 results highlights a striking dichotomy. The core business segment, "Passenger Cars and Light Commercial Vehicles," despite generating €220 billion in revenue, saw its operating profit collapse to €13.6 billion in 2024, down from €19.4 billion the previous year. This margin contraction, occurring despite rising revenues, signals an inability to fully pass on cost inflation (energy, labor, software R&D) to final prices, or a less favorable product mix.

Conversely, the "Commercial Vehicles" division stands out as a robust growth driver, posting a 12% revenue CAGR over 5 years and a record operating profit of €4.2 billion in 2024. Similarly, Financial Services continue to act as a cyclical buffer with steadily rising revenue (9% CAGR), although their contribution to profit slightly retreated in 2024, likely a victim of higher interest rates affecting refinancing margins.

Geographic Dynamics: The Chinese Dilemma and the European Fortress

The geographic breakdown of performance is equally instructive. Europe remains the Group's stronghold, generating €132 billion and maintaining stable growth. North America confirms its status as the new growth engine with a 9% revenue CAGR, validating the local industrial expansion strategy (notably with the Scout brand and battery investments).

However, the Asia-Pacific region is the nerve center of concern. Sales volumes have dropped alarmingly (-7% unit CAGR between 2019 and 2024), and revenues are stagnant (0% growth). Volkswagen is losing ground in China, its largest historical market, facing the meteoric rise of local EV manufacturers (BYD, NIO) who are enforcing a fierce price war and hold a technological lead in "software-defined vehicles."

Strategic Levers and Recent Developments

1. Rationalization and "Performance Program": Faced with declining profitability in the "Passenger Cars" segment, management has intensified its savings plan aiming for €10 billion by 2026. This involves reducing model complexity and, a socially explosive topic, potential adjustments to production capacities in Germany.

2. Electrification and Software (CARIAD): The transition to electric vehicles (BEV) remains the priority, but delays in the CARIAD software division have weighed on key product launches (Porsche Macan EV, Audi Q6 e-tron). 2025 marks an attempt to regain control via strategic partnerships (notably with Xpeng in China) to bridge the technological gap.

3. Volume vs. Value: Data shows a structural decline in global volumes (-4% unit CAGR since 2019), dropping from nearly 11 million vehicles to around 9 million. This contraction, accepted to favor margins, hits its limits when fixed costs are no longer sufficiently absorbed, as evidenced by the 2024 operating profit drop.

Conclusion and Outlook

Volkswagen is at a crossroads. While geographic diversification towards North America and the strength of the Heavy Truck segment are undeniable assets, the deterioration of core automotive profitability and the hemorrhaging of market share in China constitute major risks for stock valuation. Experts must closely monitor the Group's ability to stabilize margins in 2025 and execute its software roadmap without further delays.

Volkswagen_2024.pdf

Download PDF • 338KB